A lot of Religious Right people in America complain about anti-Christian persecution in other countries. I am more or less okay with them being concerned about that, although I think they tend to target countries that they don’t like for other reasons and I wouldn’t be surprised if they sometimes exaggerate the degree of persecution. The main problem though, is that they were silent during decades of Catholics being, to one degree or another, oppressed in Northern Ireland. There WERE other factors that determined how Catholics were treated (anti-Irish bigotry) and some Catholics were Unionists (supported N. Ireland remaining in the UK) but anti-Catholic bigotry was a big factor in how Catholics were treated. Read this and this (the first of those two links is the more relevant one) and maybe a sort of relevant post I did in June about anti-Catholic bigotry in America.
The Pope has never visited N. Ireland and there’s a reason for that. British Prime Minister Tony Blair didn’t convert to Catholicism until AFTER he resigned and there’s a reason for that. And until recently the Monarch of the UK couldn’t be a Catholic or MARRIED to a Catholic (that second part has been changed, but not the first part).
(I’m not saying that Catholics are prevented from practicing their faith, but if you read that post, you’ll see there were a lot of ways where the government, at every level, was anti-Catholic (bear in mind that the Army was controlled by London and almost the entire time during The Troubles, the police were also controlled by London))
They also support Israel, even though the extreme Zionist nature of the State is meant to exclude, among others, Christians (I know that there are moderate Zionists who don’t believe that Jews should be 100% of the State when 20% of the population is not Jewish). 2% of the population, according to Wikipedia, is Christian, and as Palestinians they are treated very badly as I explain here. Some would say it’s not motivated by anti-Christian bias and that might be true, but the Christian population IS treated horribly. And these American Christians I’m talking about are at least mostly Evangelicals and Evangelicals are among the most passionate supporters of Israel.
They were also silent during Indonesia’s genocidal occupation of East Timor. The East Timorese are Catholic and the Indonesians are Muslim. When I listened to a recording of Noam Chomsky talking about East Timor, he was introduced by a graduate student who had researched East Timor and who said that it had become a religious conflict (I can’t remember to what degree it had become a religious conflict according to him). But, because the leader of Indonesia was anti-Communist, the US supported Indonesia.
(And these people hate Muslims and love talking about Muslims hating Christians, but weren't at all alarmed about Catholics being oppressed by Muslims- they must really be unconcerned about Catholics (see below) (if you're getting the wrong idea, see this))
I just did a search and looked at several results and as far as I can tell, a lot of Evangelicals don’t believe that Catholics are Christians.
Here are my thoughts on the idea that Catholics aren’t Christians.
A: With the exception of a tiny minority (about 1% if not less) called “Radical, Traditionalist Catholics,” who I believe have been told by the Vatican to fuck off, we recognize Protestants as Christians.
B: It’s simply sectarian.
C: We believe that Christ was the Son of God.
D: As far as I can tell, these Evangelicals who don’t believe Catholics are Christians recognize other Protestants as Protestant even though they have some different ideas about Protestantism and Christianity in general.
No comments:
Post a Comment